by 2cold on 15 Aug 2008, 23:16
I put my opinions in brackets....
Calcio Debate: Who Should Lippi Purge From Euro 2008?
Marcello Lippi will tomorrow name the first squad of his new Italy reign. Who should the World Cup-winning coach purge from the Euro 2008 disappointment?
It has been stated on numerous occasions, since Euro 2008, that the time has now come for the Italy national team to turn the page, and begin a new youthful era ahead of the 2010 World Cup.
Marcello Lippi has returned with the objective of repeating the glorious success from Germany, and tomorrow he will name his first new squad for next Wednesday’s friendly against Austria in Nice.
We shouldn’t read too much into Lippi’s selections for this clash, as the coach, who is desperate for a winning start, has already stated that he will call upon those who are further ahead in their pre-season preparation. This guarantees “several” Juventus additions, as well as Liverpool’s Andrea Dossena, and possibly Fiorentina’s Alberto Gilardino and Napoli’s Christian Maggio.
However, looking slightly further ahead to the group that Lippi plans to build his 2010 World Cup around - who should the coach banish from the regime of his predecessor, Roberto Donadoni.
Below is the original 23-man squad list for Euro 2008. I offer my opinion, giving a ‘Yes, No, or Maybe’, on whether or not each player should be part of Lippi’s new era. It is then up to you to have your say.
Gianluigi Buffon (30) Juventus: The best goalkeeper in the world. Nothing more to add. Verdict: Yes (ahh yeah)
Christian Panucci (35) Roma: Did very well at Euro 2008 but he will be 37 in 2010, and he doesn’t get on with Lippi. Verdict: No (I agree, Lippi never goes for this)
Fabio Grosso (30) Lyon: One of Italy’s best players in Austria and Switzerland, and is still in peak physical condition. He should definitely begin the new World Cup campaign, before another assessment in later 2009. Verdict: Maybe ( A definate yes...)
Giorgio Chiellini (24) Juventus : His development over the past 12 months has been frightening. Now has the potential to be one of the best defenders in Europe. Verdict: Should Bacary Sagna change his hairstyle? (agreed)
Fabio Cannavaro (34) Real Madrid: Has there ever been a player so proud of his nationality? He will be 36 in 2010 but his influence in the dressing room cannot be underestimated. Verdict: Yes, unless his form drops drastically. (for now yes, start to fade him out and groom someone else)
Andrea Barzagli (27) Wolfsburg : Has potentially thrown away his career by moving to Wolfsburg. Unlikely to improve in the Bundesliga, which is a worry given his Euro 2008 display. Verdict: Were South Korea worthy 2002 World Cup semi-finalists? (depth)
Alessandro Del Piero (33) Juventus: A club legend but has never done it for Italy. It is time to give the likes of Cassano, Balotelli, Rossi and Giovinco a chance. Verdict: No (no, its time to move on)
Gennaro Gattuso (30) Milan: Having seen him in pre-season, he shows no signs of getting his physical sharpness back. His legs appear to have gone. Verdict: No (see above)
Luca Toni (31) Bayern Munich: Disastrous Euro 2008, and he will be 33 by the time of South Africa. Getting rid of Toni will bring the best out of skilful players like Cassano, and will stop the temptation of lumping forward long balls. Verdict: No
(see above)
Daniele De Rossi (24) Roma: The future of the Italy midfield. He should be close to his peak in two years time. Verdict: Did Pele include the goals he scored in Escape To Victory in his ridiculously over exaggerated career total? (agreed)
Antonio Di Natale (30) Udinese: Perhaps was not give a fair crack at the Euros, but he also needs to make way for the host of young attackers. Verdict: Will Udinese win Serie A this year? (depth)
Marco Borriello (25) Milan: This year will tell whether or not he was a one-season wonder. Needs to prove himself at a big club like Milan before he can be trusted for Italy. Verdict: Maybe (replace Toni....depth)
Massimo Ambrosini (31) Milan: Do I really need to answer this? Verdict: Yes, but only if every other midfielder in Italy is injured. (no, we have to go with youth)
Marco Amelia (26) Palermo: I once had serious doubts about Amelia but he largely impressed me last season. Will be a solid backup to Buffon. Verdict: Yes (yes, although I liked that keeper who plays for Torino...can`t remember his name)
Fabio Quagliarella (25) Udinese: Granted just a few minutes at the Euros, but he has an explosive quality to him that suggests he will be part of the 2010 set-up. Verdict: Yes (agreed)
Mauro Camoranesi (31) Juventus: His technical ability and style means that, providing he stays fit, he will probably still be useful into his mid-30s. Verdict: Yes (Id keep him, but only for depth)
Morgan De Sanctis (31) Galatasaray: Buffon and Amelia will be the two goalkeepers in qualifying, while the third spot in South Africa should go to a youngster. Verdict: Will England win the 2010 World Cup? (no, lets promote a younger keeper)
Antonio Cassano (26) Sampdoria: His talent is unquestionable but he needs to play next to an intelligent striker with good movement. Lippi will hopefully find a way to get the best out of him. Verdict: Is Cassano crazy? (for me he should be starting)
Gianluca Zambrotta (31) Milan: I have my doubts about the physical decline of Zambrotta, so a lot will depend on his Milan form. Verdict: Maybe (see Cannavaro)
Simone Perrotta (30) Roma: A box-to-box player whose legs also seem to be going. I would be surprised if he made it to South Africa. Verdict: Is Alessio Secco related to Einstein? (nope)
Andrea Pirlo (29) Milan: Irreplaceable, as the Spain quarter final proved. Will be 31 in 2010, but age is irrelevant with Pirlo. I wouldn’t be shocked if he was still playing for Italy at the 2014 World Cup. Verdict: Do Inter have a lot of South Americans?
(fuck yeah)
Alberto Aquilani (24) Roma: Was nervous at the Euros, but he will surely develop into an outstanding player. Verdict: Yes
(yes, he should take camo spot)
Marco Materazzi (34) Inter: May have already played his last game for Italy, and indeed it would be a disaster if Lippi even considered the Matrix as part of his plans. Verdict: Is Raymond Domenech a good coach? (my brain hurts....)